What do we owe other people?
When does being a good person become an unreasonable demand for self-sacrifice?
The Six Swans
Vol. I, No. 49Susan Wolf · moral saintsSix years of silence, and she nearly burns at the stake rather than speak. Is she a moral saint, and would Wolf want her to be one?
The White Snake
Vol. I, No. 17Motive and moral desertEvery kindness gets repaid. Is it still kindness if the world always pays you back?
The Old Grandfather and the Grandson
Vol. I, No. 78Shame vs. guiltThe parents change once they see themselves through their child's eyes. Is that shame or guilt, and does it matter?
Hansel and Gretel
Vol. I, No. 15When rules breakIn the first edition it's their own mother who wants them gone. The children trick and kill to survive. Which rules were they allowed to break?
Godfather Death
Vol. I, No. 44When rules breakThe doctor breaks Death's rule twice to save a life. Love, greed, or both?
- #35: Susan Wolf, “Moral Saints”Good in Theory · 2021 · 26 min
A clear walkthrough of Wolf's argument that no rational person should want to be a saint. Pairs with The Six Swans.
- #36: Moral Saints 2 — Why Be a Saint?Good in Theory · 2021 · 34 min · Optional
Pushes back on Wolf with Peter Singer and Larissa MacFarquhar's Strangers Drowning. Singer is also Schur's Ch. 9, so this bridges into Meeting III.